The scores
Each platform was scored out of 10 on five criteria. These are our scores from building the same store hands-on in November 2026, not a lab benchmark.
| Criteria | Shopify | WooCommerce | Medusa |
|---|---|---|---|
| Setup | 9 | 4 | 4 |
| AI agents | 6 | 4 | 10 |
| Performance | 9 | 8 | 8 |
| Cost | 6 | 6 | 8 |
| Custom features | 4 | 6 | 10 |
| Total | 34 / 50 | 28 / 50 | 40 / 50 |
How we tested
To keep it fair, we built the same store for a fictional coffee roaster, Odd Hours, on each platform and did the same work on all three:
- Product upload: six coffees from one CSV file that was not formatted for any platform.
- Theme from Figma: the same homepage, product page, cart and checkout design.
- Custom feature: a build-your-own sampler. The customer picks any three coffees and gets a 100 gram bag of each, and the store has to track inventory for each coffee picked.
- Pricing and performance: the real cost of running the store, and a PageSpeed Insights test with no optimization work.
We also tested how far AI agents could take each build: Shopify's built-in Sidekick, and Claude Code connected to each platform.
A disclosure: 306 Technologies is a Medusa expert agency and we build on Medusa for clients. We used to do a lot of Shopify work too. The notes below include where Medusa fell short.
Shopify: fastest to launch, hardest to customize
Shopify was live in about 20 minutes. Sidekick, the built-in AI agent, imported our products from the unformatted CSV without help.
The theme was harder. We gave Sidekick the Figma homepage and the block it generated was not close to the design. Connecting Claude Code to the store and to Figma worked far better: it wrote custom Liquid templates and the result matched the design.
Two limits showed up after that. The checkout could not be customized to match our design, which is a Shopify limitation even on Shopify Plus. And the sampler had no clean native setup. Built as one product, every combination of three coffees becomes its own variant, and inventory is tracked per variant, so you cannot tell how many bags of one coffee are left. Sidekick recommended the Shopify Bundles app, which meant creating a bundle for every combination, and Sidekick could not create those bundles inside the app for us.
- Strengths: setup speed, performance out of the box, product import with Sidekick.
- Gaps: no custom checkout, custom features depend on apps and workarounds, and costs add up across the plan, payment fees and apps.
WooCommerce: you own the code, and every setup step
WooCommerce is a free, open-source plugin that runs on WordPress. You can host it anywhere, which you cannot do with Shopify. The other side of that is that hosting, maintenance and security are yours to handle.
Setup took much longer. We hosted WordPress on Railway, installed WooCommerce, and used Claude Code to upload the products, since there is no AI agent in the dashboard. Claude Code also built the custom theme from the Figma design. Getting the theme connected and deployed took a while.
The payoff is control. We built the exact checkout from our design, which was not possible on Shopify.
The sampler was still a problem. There is no native way to handle it. The realistic options were two paid WooCommerce extensions or custom code. We used a product bundles extension, where half the settings were locked behind a premium plan, and ended up with three "slot" items that each hold the six coffees. It works, and it would be painful to manage.
- Strengths: full ownership of code and checkout, no platform subscription, no third-party transaction fee.
- Gaps: slow setup, a dashboard that is not built for e-commerce, and custom features that depend on paid extensions.
Medusa: slowest start, most flexible
Medusa is an open-source, API-first e-commerce framework. It gives you a commerce engine that any storefront can connect to, so a website, a point-of-sale system and a wholesale portal can all run through one backend. It is a framework, not a hosted platform, so you need a developer to set it up.
Claude Code set up the project, wrote a seed script for the products and built the storefront from the Figma design. Like WooCommerce, the checkout matched our design.
The sampler is where Medusa pulled ahead. Even the basic setup tracks the individual inventory items behind each variant, so stock for one coffee is counted across every combination it appears in. We then moved to a cleaner structure: one display product that holds the price and images, and one hidden product with six variants that holds the inventory. Adding a seventh coffee means adding one variant, not rebuilding every combination. The logic lives inside the commerce backend, not in an app on top of it.
- Strengths: custom features built into the commerce logic, full control of the checkout and codebase, and the best experience working with AI agents (Medusa has its own MCP server and agent skills).
- Gaps: you need a developer, and setup takes longer than Shopify.
What each platform costs
| Shopify | WooCommerce | Medusa | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform fee | About $50 to $3,400 a month (CAD) | Free, open source | Free, open source |
| Hosting | Included | About $30 to a few hundred dollars a month for managed WordPress hosting | Medusa Cloud from $29 a month, or host it yourself |
| Payment fees | 2.5% to 2.8% + 30 cents with Shopify Payments | 2.9% + 30 cents with WooPayments | Your payment provider's rate |
| Fee for using your own payment provider | 2% on the Basic plan | None | None |
| Add-ons | Paid apps | Paid extensions | Third-party services you choose |
Prices are from November 2026 and will change.
Which should you choose?
Choose Shopify: you need to sell this week
Your store fits a standard e-commerce setup and you want it live quickly without a developer.
Choose WooCommerce: you already run on WordPress
You are comfortable in the WordPress ecosystem, want to own your code and checkout, and can live with a longer setup and paid extensions.
Choose Medusa: the custom parts are the business
Your pricing, products or checkout do not fit a standard store, and you have a developer or the budget to hire one. If we were building Odd Hours for a real client, this is the one we would pick.
Frequently asked questions
Is Medusa better than Shopify?
In our test Medusa scored 40 out of 50 and Shopify 34. Medusa won on custom features, cost and working with AI agents. Shopify won clearly on setup: it was live in about 20 minutes with no developer. For a standard store that needs to launch fast, Shopify is the better choice. For a store with custom requirements, Medusa is.
Is WooCommerce cheaper than Shopify?
WooCommerce has no monthly platform fee and no third-party transaction fee, but you pay for hosting (about $30 to a few hundred dollars a month for managed WordPress hosting) and for extensions. We scored both platforms 6 out of 10 on cost, because the costs move from the subscription to hosting and extensions.
Can you customize the Shopify checkout?
Not fully. We could not match our checkout design on Shopify, and that limit applies even on Shopify Plus. On WooCommerce and Medusa we built the exact checkout from the design.
Which platform works best with AI agents?
Medusa scored 10 out of 10. It has its own MCP server and agent skills, and Claude Code handled setup, product import and the storefront. Shopify's Sidekick was good at product import and weak at building a theme from a design. WooCommerce has no built-in agent, and connecting one took more manual steps.
Do you need a developer for Medusa?
Yes. Medusa is a developer-first framework. That is why it scored 4 out of 10 for setup, the same as WooCommerce.
Are these results still current?
We tested in November 2026. Prices, plans and AI features on all three platforms change often, so check current pricing before you decide.


